Guarantees of origin: Bureaucracy slows down green tenant electricity

Outdated bureaucratic hurdles in issuing certificates of origin currently prevent green electricity from commercial facilities from being officially declared as such. Cumbersome and expensive environmental assessments often make certification unprofitable and force operators to formally classify ecologically generated energy as “grey power.”.

Electricity from commercial photovoltaic systems is undoubtedly ecological and sustainable. If it is sold to third parties, it should be labeled and treated as such from the very first kilowatt hour. For this purpose Guarantees of origin (HKN) for the producer. These are stored in a digital register of guarantees of origin and redeemed when a sale is made.

For the operator and investors of a previously non-subsidized PV system this trade in guarantees of origin is a not insignificant Source of income. Especially when it comes to certifying PV electricity and issuing HKNs puts the brakes on bureaucracy in Germany on a massive scale. No wonder, since it dates back to a time when only a few coal, gas or nuclear power plants generated electricity. Even if the solar system is installed on the same site where one or more tenants consume the PV electricity directly, problems are already occurring.

Environmental assessments for guarantees of origin are cumbersome, time-consuming and costly

node.energy, partner of CUBE CONCEPTS, has now commented on this. "In practice, it is currently almost impossible to have the electricity generated certified via guarantees of origin. This electricity must therefore be declared as "gray electricity" based on the current electricity mix in Germany." The entire HKN system is still based on the assumption that the electricity generated always corresponds to the Detour via the public grid and a dealer reaches the end consumer.

With a tenant electricity model, however, the electricity is sold directly and directly to the tenant on site. The electricity seller's photovoltaic system can even be installed on the roof of the same property where the tenant consumes it. Nevertheless, the inflexible bureaucratic processes are complied with. In such an environmental assessment, the PV system and its components are checked and additionally compared with the registration. Matthias Karger, CEO of node.energy, explains: "An environmental assessment not only costs a disproportionate amount of time, but also makes applying for the guarantees of origin so urgently required by the industry absolutely unprofitable."

Automatic metering systems must be sufficient to generate guarantees of origin


Operators must have all components certified before and at the latest when commissioning a large photovoltaic system on a commercial property. In addition, commercial PV systems require extensive electronic monitoring, measuring and control units for electricity tax registration anyway. This is required by the redispatch procedure and was stipulated in the EEG. In a public statement, node.energy therefore calls on the BMWK, representing the opinion of around 1,000 operators of such systems, to abolish the requirement for environmental reports and replace it with simple proof of the amount of electricity generated using a calibrated measuring system.

From practice

More than 300 MWp installed: References with key figures per project

Photovoltaics and battery storage for industry and commerce: performance, power output and CO₂ savings per installation, plus feedback from our customers.

Free initial consultation

Analyze load profile — get a first assessment in 30 minutes.

CUBE CONCEPTS analyzes grid connection, load profile, and price structure — manufacturer-independent, open-book, without commitment.

More interesting articles

Power grid expansion will be more expensive

Electricity grid expansion will be more expensive than planned

By 2045, grid investments will rise to around 528 billion euros to implement 18,000 km of new transmission lines and offshore connections for doubled electricity consumption. Expensive underground cable requirements, global material shortages, and the connection of decentralized renewable energy systems are driving costs far beyond previous forecasts.

Read more "
Electricity price brake: maximum values in tenders raised - Panles detail view

Electricity price brake: maximum values in tenders raised

The significant increase in tender prices to as much as 11.25 cents per kW sends a clear signal for new investments in solar power. This article examines the current legal framework and explains how companies can benefit from these improved terms through the CUBE Contracting model without exposing themselves to any capital risk.

Read more "
Aerial view of a photovoltaic system on a flat roof in black and white

DIN EN, VDE & IEC specifications for commercial PV roof systems

From grid connection to lightning protection: Adherence to DIN EN, VDE, and IEC standards is the foundation for the safe and long-lasting operation of any commercial solar system. In our overview, learn which technical regulations are absolutely essential for the planning, installation, and documentation of your photovoltaic rooftop system today.

Read more "
Solar carports - aerial view

Newsletter registration