FCR · aFRR · mFRR · Spot Arbitrage · FTM Marketing

Balancing energy with battery storage: FTM revenue for industrial storage

An industrial storage system capable of handling 1 MW of power generates daily revenue from FCR, aFRR, mFRR and spot arbitrage – fully automatically, regardless of production operations.

CUBE CONCEPTS markets industrial storage systems on the balancing energy market (FCR, aFRR, mFRR) and on the power exchange, fully automatically and without interfering with production. Direct access is possible from 1 MW; smaller systems run in a pool. CUBE CONCEPTS expects gross revenue of €240,000 to €320,000 per MW and year; according to ISEA, 2h storage systems achieved around €259,000 in 2025.

240.000–320.000 €

FTM Gross Revenue per MW/Year

CUBE CONCEPTS benchmark

+39%

aFRR capacity revenues 2025

ISEA Battery Revenue Index

1 MW

Minimum offer FCR, aFRR, mFRR

smaller systems in the pool

January 1st, 2027

Section 118: investment cut-off date

according to the AgNes draft · commissioning by 4.8.2029

§118: investment decision before 1 January 2027 according to the AgNes draft

Free · Within 5 working days · No commitment

The four FTM revenue streams

FCR · aFRR · mFRR · Spotarbitrage – a portfolio, four revenue sources

No single channel maximizes revenue permanently. The CUBE EfficiencyUnit reweights FCR, aFRR, mFRR and arbitrage daily – based on market prices, peak load time windows and your load forecast.

FCR ↘ Declining

Frequency Containment Reserve

Frequency containment reserve · full power in ≤30 seconds

Compensation

Capacity price at a uniform price (pay-as-cleared), daily auction with 4-hour products

Degradation

~0.3 full cycles/day – low

Trend

Most profitable channel in 2022/23, since declining; around €106,000/MW in 2025 (−6.9 %)

It remains a portfolio component. Source: regelleistung.net · ISEA Battery Revenue Index, revenue 2025

aFRR ↗ +39 % 2025

Automatic Frequency Restoration Reserve

Secondary control power · fully in 5 minutes

Compensation

Capacity price (pay-as-bid, daily, 4-hour products) + energy price via PICASSO

Optimum

2h system (0.5C) – strongest revenue channel in 2025

Trend

Capacity revenues 2025 +39 % to over €146,000/MW (2-hour system)

mFRR ↘ Supplementary channel

Manual Frequency Restoration Reserve

Minute reserve · Activation within 12.5 minutes

Compensation

Capacity price (pay-as-bid, daily, 4-hour products) + energy price

Activation

since 2022 through the European platform MARI

Restriction

Manual activation squanders BESS response time advantage

Supplementary channel when FCR and aFRR are not fully loaded. Source: regelleistung.net

Arbitrage ↗ Growing

Day-Ahead & Intraday · Spot arbitrage

EPEX SPOT · Day-Ahead in quarter-hours since 1.10.2025

Mechanism

Charge at negative/low prices, discharge at high prices

Market data

573 hours with negative wholesale prices in 2025 (2024: 457)

Trend

Grows with increasing share of renewable energies

Provides stability when balancing energy prices are low. Source: BNetzA/SMARD · BNetzA 2025

Portfolio Strategy: The CUBE EfficiencyUnit reweights FCR, aFRR, mFRR (as a supplementary channel) and arbitrage daily – based on market prices, peak load time windows and your load forecast. No fixed channel plan, no manual switching required.

Prerequisites

When can a battery storage system participate in the grid balancing market?

Five factors determine the FTM potential at your site. CUBE CONCEPTS analyzes all five in the first step – free of charge, based on your load profile data.

Minimum requirements

1 MW

Minimum bid size

750 kW

Entry at CUBE CONCEPTS, marketing in the pool

≤30 s

FCR: full power

5 Minutes

aFRR full response time

Prequalification: Compliance with technical requirements for connection to the utility grid, for battery storage systems in the FCR, etc. includes a minimum activation time of 15 minutes and a power reserve of 25 % CUBE CONCEPTS coordinates the prequalification as a full-service provider.

Five factors for the business case

01

Grid connection capacity

Available connection capacity determines FTM-enabled capacity

02

Storage Dimensioning (C-Rate)

2h systems achieved around €259,000/MW in 2025, 1h systems around €151,000/MW (ISEA)

03

Grid operator & grid level

Grid fees, peak load time windows, and connection conditions vary depending on the grid operator; balancing energy prices apply uniformly nationwide

04

BTM Profile §19 / §118

§19: Notification by September 30 (until 2028) · §118: Investment decision before January 1, 2027 (draft), commissioning by August 4, 2029

05

BTM/FTM Split

Remaining capacity after BTM coverage determines FTM potential

CUBE CONCEPTS analyzes all 5 factors – free of charge based on your load profile data

Who balancing energy is relevant for

Which profile applies to you?

Four decision profiles – different questions, the same basis: Open-book calculation based on your location data.

Investment Decision & Balance Sheet Clarity

“Which IRR is realistic – and how do we account for it?”

KPMG comparison calculation: IRR 10.5 % for LFP (10 MW / 40 MWh, Feb. 2026); your value results from the open-book calculation. Off-balance-sheet treatment possible with BESS Contracting (subject to IFRS 16 assessment). Open-book calculation based on your load profile – CUBE BatterySizer calculates over 250 operating variants site-specifically.

€0 CAPEX · off-balance possible (IFRS 16) · open book

Sustainability Goals & CSRD Reporting

“How does FTM marketing affect our carbon footprint?”

Participation in balancing energy = measurable, system-supportive contribution to grid stability. According to the Federal Network Agency, storage systems have a “special function in the electricity supply system of the future as a flexibility provider”. The operational data can be included in the CSRD reporting (ESRS E1).

CSRD-compatible · system-supportive · verifiable

Operational Safety & Plant Engineering

“How does the storage system integrate without interfering with our production?”

Fully automatic. The CUBE EfficiencyUnit controls FCR, aFRR and arbitrage without intervening in the PLC, control system or production control. 24/7 monitoring. Manufacturer-independent system design – at least 3 comparative offers, LCOS-assessed.

Fully automatic · no intervention · 24/7

Energy Procurement & Electricity Purchase Costs

“How can I unlock untapped FTM potential at my grid connection?”

Monthly billing per channel, OPEX displayed separately – no opaque pool billing. Market benchmarks (ISEA, KPMG) as the basis for decision-making. No manufacturer portfolio – your data, your calculation.

Open-Book · per channel · no lock-in

Revenue Numbers & Business Case

What does an industrial storage facility with FTM marketing earn?

CUBE CONCEPTS benchmark values, put into context with the ISEA Battery Revenue Index and the KPMG comparison calculation (February 2026). All values are location-dependent: grid connection, storage duration, and BTM/FTM split affect the result.

Total Gross Revenue FTM

240.000–320.000 €

per MW/year · CUBE CONCEPTS benchmark; ISEA 2025: around €259,000 for 2h storage

of which aFRR share

largest channel in 2025

aFRR capacity revenues +39 % · ISEA Battery Revenue Index

LCOS LFP – Benchmark

110 €/MWh

KPMG AG, February 2026 · Benchmark for manufacturer tenders

LCOS ZnBr (Zinc-Bromine Flow)

104 €/MWh

KPMG AG, February 2026 · lowest LCOS, long-term operation

LCOS NIB (sodium-ion battery)

127 €/MWh

little operational experience, under observation · KPMG AG, Feb. 2026

Practical example – industrial site 1 MW / 2 MWh LFP · FTM marketing

FTM Gross Revenue/Year

240.000–320.000 €

OPEX/Year (O&M, Marketing)

−€55000

Net market revenue/year

185.000–265.000 €

Contracting-Share (25 %)

~46,000–66,000 € per year

GIK (approx. 250 €/kWh)

~500.000 €

KPMG reference IRR LFP (10 MW)

10.5%

Payback

2–4 years

Purchase: Full control · 100 % net proceeds

CUBE CONCEPTS benchmark values · IRR from the KPMG comparison calculation (10 MW / 40 MWh, Feb. 2026) · Site-specific: Grid connection, storage duration, and BTM/FTM split affect the result · Free potential analysis

CUBE BatterySizer calculates over 250 operating variants on a site-specific basis · free

Control Logic & Daily Conflicts

Three conflicts per day – the CUBE EfficiencyUnit resolves them automatically

FCR, §19 compliance and arbitrage compete daily for the same storage capacity. CUBE EfficiencyUnit prioritizes automatically – without manual intervention.

01

FCR vs. Peak Shaving

FCR binds ~50 % SoC symmetrically – capacity that is missing for peak shaving.

Solution: Hourly reprioritization based on peak load time windows + load forecast + market price

02

Arbitrage vs. §19 peak load time windows

Cheap charging periods conflict with peak load time windows – charging jeopardizes §19 claims.

Solution: peak load time windows stored daily, charging automatically blocked

03

Cycle threshold

Price spread too small = cycle costs more than it yields.

Solution: Break-even calculated dynamically – only profitable cycles are executed

Illustrative daily schedule – multi-use operation

22:00–06:00

Cheap charging – Arbitrage store. FCR readiness at 50 % SoC in parallel.

06:00–08:00

Morning ramp – Check §19 peak load time windows. Build up peak shaving readiness.

08:00–12:00

Peak Shaving Active – Peak load time windows. §19 compliance automatically documented.

12:00–16:00

PV / Recharging – Self-consumption or favorable price windows.

16:00–20:00

Evening peak – Peak Shaving + Arbitrage discharge. Peak load time windows locked.

20:00–22:00

FCR / Standby – 50 % SoC. §19-year documentation is underway.

Revenue mix by location profile

What strategy suits your location?

No channel lock-in – the strategy follows the market and your load profile, not the manufacturer.

Profile 1 – High demand charge

Primary: BTM – Peak Shaving & §19

A single quarter-hour peak determines the demand charge for the entire billing year. BTM brings immediate, measurable value.

BTM comes first – FTM supplements outside the peak load time windows. §19 application deadline: September 30 (until 2028).

Profile 2 – Free grid capacity

Primary: FTM – aFRR + Arbitrage

Free grid connection capacity is the ticket to the balancing energy markets. €240,000–320,000/MW/year FTM gross revenue.

FTM comes first – the same storage system later switches to combined operation without hardware replacement; since October 2026, the allocation of electricity quantities has been governed by the MiSpeL determination.

Profile 3 – PV system available

Primary: BTM – Self-consumption + Peak Shaving

FCR possible. Arbitrage limited by EEG regulations. Since October 2026, MiSpeL has enabled combined PV + FTM.

With MiSpeL: for the first time, a PV system and FTM marketing at the same time without a remuneration conflict.

Profile 4 · Since MiSpeL (Oct. 2026)

BTM + FTM combined – full combination

MiSpeL (BNetzA determination pursuant to § 85d EEG) enables PV systems and FTM marketing for the first time without a subsidy conflict: arbitrage and EEG market premium combined.

No channel lock-in – the strategy follows the market, not the manufacturer.

Submit your load profile – CUBE CONCEPTS analyzes it free of charge

Prequalification Full Service

From load profile analysis to ongoing operation – what CUBE CONCEPTS takes care of

01

Load Profile Analysis & Open-Book Calculation

CUBE BatterySizer analyzes free grid capacity, §19 qualification, and optimal storage dimensioning – all FTM and BTM levers with Euro amounts.

Free · Within 5 working days

02

System Configuration & TSO Coordination

Measurement concept, coordination with the TSO, manufacturer tender – at least 3 offers, LCOS evaluated, manufacturer-independent.

2–4 months

03

Technical Tests & TSO Prequalification

Installation, grid connection, CUBE EfficiencyUnit configuration, prequalification with the TSO – FCR ≤30 seconds, aFRR 5 minutes.

3–6 months

04

Ongoing Operations & Billing

Bid submission, dispatch, monthly billing per channel (OPEX listed individually). 24/7 monitoring, §19 compliance documented.

20+ years

Market positioning

Market positioning – why open book instead of pool optimizers?

Most providers sell hardware or electricity. CUBE CONCEPTS builds the system behind it.

Criterion Provider optimizer CUBE CONCEPTS
Calculation basis Portfolio/Manufacturer – optimized for their own utilization Your load profile – location-specific, before you commit
Open-book Internal – not visible before contract conclusion All assumptions open · before your decision · no negotiating position
Revenue mix Often one channel – manufacturer’s optimum FCR + aFRR + mFRR as supplementary channel + dynamic arbitrage
EMS Priority Provider revenue – §19 secondary Customer interest – §19 + Peak Shaving always a priority
Pre-qualification Customer side – own effort Full-service CUBE – including TSO coordination
Billing Pool, OPEX opaque Net market revenue by channel, OPEX shown individually

Our open-book calculation is not a bargaining position – it is the foundation on which partnership works. Open-book means transparency within the business relationship – no public disclosure of project data.

Submit your load profile – we show your potential based on your data, not our portfolio

Typical objections

The most common objections – answered directly

“§19 compliance suffers when FTM is running.”

Compliance with §19 and peak shaving always take priority. FTM runs exclusively outside the peak load time windows. The CUBE EfficiencyUnit automatically blocks charging operations – no manual intervention, documented for audit purposes. §19 Application deadline: September 30th.

“What if FCR prices continue to fall?”

Portfolio strategy: FCR + aFRR + mFRR as supplementary channels + arbitrage are dynamically weighted daily. The aFRR performance revenues increased by 39 in 2025 % (ISEA Battery Revenue Index) – the channel change occurs without hardware modification. FCR remains a portfolio component, not a sole pillar.

“We don’t have any free grid capacity.”

Often, there is more available connection capacity than is known internally. CUBE BatterySizer analyzes over 250 operating variants based on your load profile data – free of charge, before you make your decision.

“We don’t know yet whether we want Contracting or a purchase.”

That is not a reason for rejection. The open-book calculation shows both models side by side – based on the same location, the same numbers. Contracting (0 € CAPEX, 25 % share) or purchase (100 % revenue): CUBE CONCEPTS calculates both before you make a decision.

References

150+ energy projects completed across Europe. Tušimice battery storage with 50 MW / 100 MWh currently under construction.

Selected industrial companies for which CUBE CONCEPTS has completed energy projects, so far in photovoltaics. Currently under construction: Tušimice battery storage, 50 MW / 100 MWh, first expansion stage.

TI Automotive

Magna

Valeo

Voestalpine

Tenneco

ITW

Frequently asked questions

Balancing energy & FTM – Answers for decision-makers

What is FCR and how does a battery storage system earn money with it?

FCR (Frequency Containment Reserve) must deliver full power within 30 seconds. Availability is remunerated: daily auction the day before with six 4-hour products, uniform price (pay-as-cleared). Around 0.3 full cycles per day, therefore low degradation. FCR revenues have been declining since 2023 (2025: around €106,000/MW, −6.9 % according to ISEA), but FCR remains a portfolio component.

aFRR (automatic Frequency Restoration Reserve) must deliver full power within 5 minutes. Both capacity (daily auction, 4-hour products, pay-as-bid) and activated energy (European platform PICASSO) are remunerated. According to the ISEA Battery Revenue Index, aFRR capacity revenues of a 2-hour storage system increased by 39 % to over €146,000/MW in 2025, while revenues across all markets fell by 16 %.

The minimum bid size for FCR, aFRR and mFRR is 1 MW; smaller systems are marketed through a prequalified provider in the pool. CUBE CONCEPTS implements storage units from 750 kW. Proof of compliance includes, among other things, the activation times (FCR 30 seconds, aFRR 5 minutes, mFRR 12.5 minutes). CUBE CONCEPTS performs the prequalification as a full-service provider.

CUBE CONCEPTS expects €240,000–320,000 FTM gross revenue per MW and year; according to the ISEA Battery Revenue Index, the potential of a 2-hour storage system was around €259,000/MW in 2025. Site-specific; the cost benchmark is the LCOS, for LFP 110 €/MWh (KPMG AG, Feb. 2026). Free potential analysis.

CUBE calculates based on your load profile – open book; all assumptions are disclosed before you commit. Pool optimizers calculate based on their portfolio. The result: calculation in the customer’s interest, not the provider’s interest.

Charging at negative or favorable prices, discharging at high prices, on the day-ahead market (in quarter-hour intervals since October 1, 2025) and in intraday trading. In 2025, there were 573 hours in Germany with negative wholesale prices (2024: 457). Arbitrage stabilizes revenues when balancing energy prices are low. Source: Federal Network Agency/SMARD.

Yes, the CUBE EfficiencyUnit coordinates automatically. BTM (§19 application deadline 30 September) has priority. FTM runs in free capacity windows. MiSpeL: PV + FTM combined since October 2026. §118: investment decision before 1 January 2027 according to the AgNes draft, commissioning by 4 August 2029.

Next step

Analyze FTM potential – location-specific and free of charge

CUBE CONCEPTS calculates based on your load profile: free grid capacity, optimal storage dimensioning, FCR/aFRR/arbitrage potential, and your revenue expectation – open book, before your decision.

§118: investment decision before 1 January 2027 according to the AgNes draft

Free · Within 5 working days · No commitment · §118: investment decision before 1 Jan 2027 (AgNes draft)

Search

What are you looking for?

Results starting with 3 characters · Enter all hits · Esc close · Ctrl+K opens the search everywhere

Frequently searched for

Solar carports - aerial view

Newsletter registration