What are fuel-switch power plants? Efficiency, costs & opportunities

They are intended to secure the coal phase-out and stabilize the electricity supply during periods of darkness. But how efficient, economical, and sustainable is the transition from coal to gas and, in the long term, hydrogen?

Fuel-Switch power plants These are power plants whose fuel is being converted from coal to natural gas and, in the future, to hydrogen. In Germany, they are intended to ensure controllable power capacity as coal production declines, when wind and solar power plants do not provide sufficient electricity.

However, the term is often used inaccurately. Sometimes it is used in a Retrofitting existing coal-fired boilers I mean, sometimes a New construction of modern gas and steam turbine systems (GuD) at the former coal-fired power plant site. This distinction has major implications for efficiency, carbon dioxide balance, investment costs, and future profitability.

What does Fuel Switch mean?

Fuel Switch literally means „fuel metabolism“. In the German energy industry, it usually refers to the two-stage conversion from Coal to natural gas and later by Natural gas to hydrogen.

  • Phase 1: A coal-fired power plant is converted to natural gas or replaced with a gas plant.
  • Phase 2: The plant will be gradually or completely converted to hydrogen.
  • Goal: They receive regulated electricity and, if necessary, district heating power, reduce emissions and enable the transition to a climate-neutral electricity supply.

EnBW explicitly describes the Fuel Switch as a „double“ fuel conversion: first coal to natural gas, then natural gas to hydrogen.

How does a Fuel-Switch power plant work?

Coal-fired power plants generate electricity by burning coal in a steam boiler. The resulting steam drives a steam turbine and a generator.

To switch over the operation of a real fuel switch to modern GuD technology, the old coal-fired boilers are shut down and replaced with gas turbines. The gas turbine generates electricity directly; its hot waste heat generates additional steam for a steam turbine. This creates a combined gas and steam process system.

A fuel switch is therefore not simply a change in the burner. Depending on the project, this includes new turbines, boilers, exhaust systems, pipes, control technology, and adjustments to cooling systems, water treatment, and the connection to the grid.

Efficiency rates: Old construction vs. new construction

The efficiency rate describes the proportion of the fuel energy used that ends up as usable electrical energy. In combined heat and power (CHP) systems, the power plant uses the additional heat directly, so that the Overall utilization rate increasing significantly.

System typeTypical efficiencyClassification
Existing coal blockabout 35 to 46%Modern coal-fired power plants can achieve about 43 to 46%; lignite blocks often fall below this figure.
Upgraded coal-fired boiler converted to gasabout 35 to 45%The existing steam turbine technology limits the efficiency; the conversion is more economical but less efficient.
New GuD power plant blockup to about 65%Modern GUD systems use the waste heat from the gas turbine to also power a steam turbine.
GuD with district heatingelectric efficiency plus heat utilizationWith CHP, the overall utilization of fuel energy increases significantly; the electrical efficiency remains the decisive comparison value.

Practical classification: An upgraded old coal block can quickly and relatively cheaply provide additional secure power. However, for every kilowatt-hour produced, it requires more fuel than a modern new-build GDi unit, and therefore tends to cause higher fuel and CO₂ costs at the same gas price.

Costs: Investment, capacity, and electricity price

The cost of a Fuel Switch depends heavily on whether only the existing boiler is retrofitted or a complete GUD system is built anew.

Cost positionRetrofitting existing coal-fired power plantConstruction of a new GUD facility
Investment costsSignificantly lower; industry estimates cite about 20 to 25% of the cost of a new build.Significantly higher, because gas turbines, steam turbines, boilers, pipelines and parts of the infrastructure are being built anew.
Existing infrastructurePower lines, cooling towers, water treatment systems and transformers can often be reused.Also usable when the location and network capacity are suitable.
EfficiencyMost often lower, about 35 to 45%Up to about 65%
Fuel costs per kWhHigher, because more gas is needed per kWh produced.Lower, because less gas is needed per kWh produced.
CO₂ emissionsLower than coal, but higher than efficient GUD operation.Lower than with the renovation of old blocks.
Future securityIt is questionable whether a second conversion to hydrogen is economically viable.It is usually better if the system is planned to be H₂-ready from the outset.

Current figures from the capacity tender

In the first Gas power plant tender For long-term capacities after the StromVKG, the average quantity-weighted surcharge value was 155,296 euros per megawatt of reduced output per year. The Federal Network Agency only compensates for 85 percent of the installed capacity as „reduced capacity“.

  • The permissible maximum value was 244,000 euros per rMW per year.
  • A minimum investment of 431,000 euros per reduced megawatt required.
  • LEAG has estimated the costs for its seven fuel switch and new construction projects at 1.5 to 2 billion euros.
  • EnBW is investing in its three Fuel-Switch projects in Stuttgart-Münster, Altbach/Deizisau and Heilbronn in total 1.6 billion euros.

Important: These figures are not directly comparable. The surcharge value is an annual capacity remuneration, whereas the investment amount describes one-time construction and conversion costs. For a reliable economic calculation, fuel prices, full-load hours, CO₂ costs, network fees, maintenance, and the subsequent hydrogen conversion must be considered together.

CO₂ balance: Gas is better, but not climate neutral

The switch from coal to natural gas significantly reduces direct emissions. According to EnBW, emissions from natural gas are as low as 0.408 kg CO₂ equivalents per kWh, in the case of lignite at 1,073 kg and in the case of coal at 0.970 kg. Depending on the coal type and the efficiency of the installation, savings of up to 60% possible.

FuelCO₂ equivalents per kWhClassification
Brown coal1,073 kgHigh emissions
Coal0.970 kgHigh emissions
Natural gas0.408 kgSignificantly lower, but not emission-free
Green hydrogenPractically no direct CO₂ emissions during combustionThe climatic effect depends primarily on the production process.

Hydrogen is only climate-friendly if it is produced predominantly with renewable electricity. According to EnBW, hydrogen from natural gas generates approximately 0.3 kg CO₂ per kWh of hydrogen, In the case of coal, even around 0.57 kg.

What does „H₂-ready“ mean?

H₂-ready This does not automatically mean that operators of a fuel-switch power plant can today use hydrogen directly 100% of the time. It only means that such a power plant has been designed or built in such a way that a later conversion is technically and economically possible.

Complete hydrogen conversion requires, among other things:

  • Customized burners and combustion chambers because hydrogen burns faster and hotter.
  • Suitable materials, seals, and pipes because hydrogen has smaller molecules and can cause material erosion.
  • Higher volume flows as well as adapted conveying and processing systems.
  • Access to an adequate hydrogen supply and the hydrogen network.

Modern gas turbines, which initially run only on natural gas, tolerate the gradual addition of hydrogen. EnBW cites percentages of up to 75%, before a complete switch to 100% hydrogen becomes possible.

What role do fuel-switching power plants play?

Fuel-switch power plants are intended to supply electricity primarily when renewable energy sources are insufficient – for example, during periods of high demand. Dark doldrums. They should therefore not be considered a substitute for wind and solar power, but rather a Flexibility and safety module be in the power system.

Its advantages are:

  • Regulated power: They can be supplied when needed, regardless of wind and sun.
  • Quick availability: Modern gas power plants can be controlled flexibly and complement variable renewable energy sources.
  • Use of existing locations: The mains connection, cooling systems, transformers and water treatment systems are often retained.
  • Heat supply: Especially in cities, they can supply both electricity and district heating at the same time.
  • Reduced emissions: The transition from coal to gas significantly reduces CO₂ emissions.

Where are fuel-switching power plants being built?

In Germany, there are both completed pioneering projects and numerous large-scale facilities under construction or in advanced planning in the case of Fuel-Switch power plants.

LocationOperatorElectrical powerStatusCommissioning
Stuttgart-Münster (BW)EnBW238 MWIn operation2025 (to be achieved)
Frankfurt am Main – HKW West (HE)Mainova124 MWIn construction2026
Hamburg-Dradenau (HH)Hamburger Energiewerke180 MWIn constructionEnd of 2026
Altbach/Deizisau (BW)EnBW665 MWIn constructionQ2/2027
Heilbronn – HLB 8 (BW)EnBW675 MWIn constructionQ3/Q4 2027
Lippendorf (SN)LEAG875 MWPartly approved2029
Black pump (SN)LEAG875 MWPartly approved2029
Jänschwalde (BB)LEAG900 MWIn approval2029
Schkopau (ST)Saale Energy783 MWIn approval2029
Großkrotzenburg – Staudinger 8 (HE)Uniper890 MWIn approval2030
Bergkamen (NW)Icons880 MWIn approval2030
Weisweiler (NW)RWE Generation800 MWReceive a surcharge2031
Voerde (NW)RWE Generation800 MWReceive a surcharge2031
Werne – Gersteinwerk L (NW)RWE Generation800 MWReceive a surcharge2031
Mehrum (NI)EPH1,200 MWPreliminary ruling is pendingopen
Burghausen (BY)RWE950 MWIn planningopen
Bexbach (SL)Icons900 MWIn planningopen
Karlsruhe – RDK 9 (BW)EnBW850 MWIn planning2030
Gelsenkirchen – Scholven II (NW)Uniper835 MWIn planning2030
Weiher/Quierschied (SL)Icons600 MWIn planningopen
Leipheim II (BY)LEAG550 MWIn planningopen
Fenne/Völklingen (SL)Icons150 MWIn planningopen

Legal and regulatory framework

Fuel-Switch projects can continue to participate in the long-term capacity tenders under the StromVKG. The Federal Network Agency clarifies that the conversion of a coal-fired power plant to gaseous fuels is fundamentally a mandatory shutdown of the production facility represents.

In addition, among other things:

  • Minimum investment: 431,000 euros per reduced megawatt.
  • Emission limit value: 550 grams of CO₂ from fossil fuels per kilowatt-hour produced.
  • Power connection: A binding commitment to sufficient connection capacity is required.
  • Hydrogen concept: With natural gas as the main fuel, a plan for the subsequent transition to hydrogen must be presented.
  • Availability: The systems must be able to feed at least ten consecutive hours of power into the grid with at least 80 percent of the installed capacity.

The subsidized power plants are not reserve power plants, but Market-based power plants. They are allowed to participate in the electricity market, but they must fulfill their capacity commitment, especially during price spikes.

Challenges and criticism

Fuel-switch power plants are considered an important bridging technology for the coal phase-out, but also a transitional solution with a risk of lock-in. The most important open questions concern cost-effectiveness, climate balance, and regional distribution.

  • Lower efficiency in old buildings: Retrofitted coal blocks require more gas per kWh produced than new GUD plants.
  • Slower start-up times: Rebuilt steam power plant blocks are heavy and take several hours to start up.
  • Double conversion: First gas, then hydrogen can become expensive; the economic viability of a second transition is uncertain.
  • Hydrogen availability: Germany needs electrolysis capacities, import structures and a hydrogen network.
  • Regional distribution: In the first tender, only two plants with 314 MW and six percent went to Bavaria and Baden-Württemberg. Critics warn of higher redispatch costs due to an unfavorable regional distribution.
  • Climate relevance: Gas is a transitional technology, but not a climate-neutral end state. What is crucial is the rapid transition to green hydrogen or other emission-free options.

Who are Fuel-Switch power plants relevant for?

Fuel-switch power plants are particularly relevant for:

  • Energy providers and power plant operators, who want to further develop the existing coal sites economically.
  • Industrial sites, which require reliable power and process heat.
  • Municipalities with district heating networks, Because gas and hydrogen plants can provide both heat and electricity at the same time.
  • Grid operator, which require additional secured power at network-critical locations.
  • Investors and project developers, to strategically assess the capacity markets, location advantages and hydrogen readiness.

Frequently asked questions

Is a fuel switch power plant a gas power plant?

Not necessarily. A fuel switch plant can be an upgraded coal-fired power plant that subsequently burns gas, or a new GuD plant at the former coal site. What matters is the fuel switch, not just the technology.

Are fuel-switching power plants climate neutral?

No. Switching from coal to natural gas reduces emissions, but still produces CO₂. The operation becomes climate neutral only with green hydrogen, whose production, transportation, and combustion are low-emission processes.

What does a Fuel-Switch power plant cost?

Retrofitting can be significantly cheaper than building new facilities; industry estimates indicate that the cost of new construction is approximately 20 to 25 percent of the cost of building new facilities. At the same time, higher fuel costs due to lower efficiency can partially offset savings in operation.

Is a fuel switch economically worthwhile?

This depends primarily on the planned operating time. With few full-load hours, the low investment cost can outweigh the higher efficiency of a new GDi power plant.

What is the difference between Fuel Switch and GuD?

Fuel Switch describes the fuel exchange process. GuD describes power plant technology: a gas turbine and a steam turbine are combined to additionally utilize the waste heat from the gas turbine. A Fuel Switch can be implemented with a GuD system, but it is not required.

From practice

More than 300 MWp installed: References with key figures per project

Photovoltaics and battery storage for industry and commerce: performance, power output and CO₂ savings per installation, plus feedback from our customers.

Free initial consultation

Analyze load profile — get a first assessment in 30 minutes.

CUBE CONCEPTS analyzes grid connection, load profile, and price structure — manufacturer-independent, open-book, without commitment.

More interesting articles

Solar energy from solar power plants

Solar energy from solar power plants

Solar power plants offer an environmentally friendly alternative to fossil fuels, convincing with falling costs and high scalability. From parabolic troughs to modern large-scale PV systems, this article sheds light on how different technologies efficiently convert solar radiation into energy and reduce dependence on volatile markets.

Read more "
Electric vans for the company fleet - Parked vehicles

Electric Transporters for the Company Fleet: Sensible or Nice-to-have?

Whether for city logistics or craft businesses: switching to electric commercial vehicles is no longer just a matter of image, but requires smart planning of charging infrastructure and load management. This article sheds light on which route profiles are worthwhile for electric vans and how funding programs pave the way for emission-free fleets.

Read more "

Search

What are you looking for?

Results starting with 3 characters · Enter all hits · Esc close · Ctrl+K opens the search everywhere

Frequently searched for

Solar carports - aerial view

Newsletter registration